Chittenango Pizza Menu With Prices (2026): Pizza, Wings, Subs & Dinners

Looking for the Chittenango Pizza menu with prices? Chittenango Pizza is a neighborhood pizzeria at 500 Genesee Street, Chittenango, New York. Its menu goes beyond cheese and specialty pizzas, with chicken wings, calzones, hot and cold subs, Italian pasta dinners, salads, and desserts.

This guide covers the restaurant’s published prices, pizza-and-wing specials, opening hours, and ordering details. Price note: The menu published through CoCardAnderson displays separate cash and card prices but does not state when those prices were last revised. The amounts below are published reference prices, not guaranteed November 2026 checkout prices. Confirm the current total and availability with Chittenango Pizza at (315) 510-2000.

Chittenango Pizza Menu Prices at a Glance

Choose a standard cheese pie or a specialty pizza, then add wings or garlic knots for a group meal. The published menu gives two price columns:

Popular Item Cash Price Card Price
Medium Cheese Pizza $13.95 $14.44
Large Cheese Pizza $16.50 $17.08
Medium Specialty Pizza $18.95 $19.61
Large Specialty Pizza $22.95 $23.75
12 Chicken Wings $14.95 $15.47
Cheese Calzone $8.95 $9.26
Chicken Riggies Dinner $15.95 $16.51

Cash and card prices are shown separately because the published menu itself differentiates them. Taxes, extra toppings, special preparations, and delivery charges may affect the final total.

Chittenango Pizza Regular Pizza Menu

Standard pizzas include cheese, garlic, thick-crust sheet pizza, and a cauliflower-base option. The menu separately lists added toppings, with a different charge for sheet pizzas and cauliflower pizzas.

Pizza Published Cash Price Published Card Price
Medium Cheese $13.95 $14.44
Large Cheese $16.50 $17.08
Medium Garlic $13.95 $14.44
Large Garlic $15.95 $16.51
Large Sicilian-style $16.95 $17.54
Large Sheet Pizza $27.95 $28.93
Medium Cauliflower Pizza $11.95 $12.37

Standard pizza toppings are listed at $2 each cash ($2.07 card). The sheet pizza lists toppings at $4 each; the cauliflower pizza lists toppings at $1.50 each. Common additions include pepperoni, sausage, chicken, extra cheese, onions, black olives, mushrooms, pineapple, broccoli, and peppers. Ask about sizes and cross-contact precautions if you are considering the cauliflower base for dietary reasons.

Specialty Pizza Menu

The published menu prices its listed specialty pizzas by size rather than giving a different amount for each recipe.

Specialty Pizza Medium Cash Large Cash
Deluxe $18.95 $22.95
Chicken Wing $18.95 $22.95
Chicken Bacon Ranch $18.95 $22.95
Meat Lovers $18.95 $22.95
Veggie $18.95 $22.95
Steak $18.95 $22.95
Hawaiian $18.95 $22.95
Mediterranean $18.95 $22.95

The corresponding published card prices are $19.61 for medium and $23.75 for large. Chicken Wing and Chicken Bacon Ranch offer a change from traditional tomato-and-cheese combinations, while Veggie and Mediterranean are worth considering if you want vegetable-led toppings. Ask the restaurant for the exact ingredients and sauce on each specialty pie.

Pizza and Wings Specials

For family orders or game nights, the published everyday specials bundle pizzas and wings. Verify that a special remains available before ordering.

Published Special Cash Card
Medium Pizza + 12 Wings $26.95 $27.89
Large Pizza + 12 Wings $29.95 $31.00
Large Pizza + 24 Wings $42.95 $44.45
Two Large Pizzas $30.95 $32.03
Two Large Pizzas + 24 Wings $55.95 $57.90
Sheet Pizza + 24 Wings $50.95 $52.73

These bundle prices offer a useful comparison against buying items separately. Ask whether pizza toppings, wing sauces, or substitutions add to the listed special price.

Chittenango Pizza Wings Menu

Both traditional and boneless wings appear on the menu. Sauce options include mild, medium, hot, BBQ, garlic Parmesan, honey BBQ, teriyaki, bourbon, and garlic.

Wings Cash Card
6 Traditional Wings $7.50 $7.76
12 Traditional Wings $14.95 $15.47
24 Traditional Wings $28.95 $29.96
36 Traditional Wings $39.95 $41.34
50 Traditional Wings $52.95 $54.80
6 Boneless Wings $6.50 $6.73
12 Boneless Wings $12.95 $13.40
24 Boneless Wings $24.95 $25.82

Split wing orders carry a published $0.75 cash charge, and char-grilled preparation carries a $1.00 cash charge. Both are popular customization options, but confirm the current availability and applicable fees.

Calzones, Pizza Rolls and Stromboli

Item Cash Card
Cheese Calzone $8.95 $9.26
Pizza Roll $8.95 $9.26
Stromboli $9.95 $10.30
Additional Calzone Topping $1.00 $1.03

A calzone is a convenient choice when you want pizza flavors in a folded crust. Pizza rolls and stromboli offer another portable alternative to a full pie. Verify fillings and whether marinara is included.

Appetizers and Garlic Knots

Appetizer Cash Card
Chicken Tenders (6) $8.95 $9.26
Mozzarella Sticks (6) $8.95 $9.26
Fried Mushrooms $8.95 $9.26
Onion Rings $6.95 $7.19
French Fries $4.50 $4.66
Loaded Fries with Bacon and Cheese $6.95 $7.19
Garlic Knots (6) $3.50 $3.62
Garlic Bread $3.50 $3.62
Garlic Bread with Cheese $4.50 $4.66

Garlic knots and mozzarella sticks are straightforward sides for a pizza order. Loaded fries can make a fuller snack, while the chicken tenders add a non-pizza choice for mixed groups.

Hot and Cold Subs Menu

Chittenango Pizza also publishes a range of hot Parmesan-style sandwiches and cold deli subs.

Sub Cash Card
Chicken Parmesan $10.95 $11.33
Meatball Parmesan $10.95 $11.33
Eggplant Parmesan $10.95 $11.33
Steak with Onion, Mushroom and Peppers $10.95 $11.33
Chicken Philly $10.95 $11.33
Chicken Bacon Ranch $10.95 $11.33
Buffalo Chicken $10.95 $11.33
Gyro $7.95 $8.23
Italian, Ham, Salami or Turkey (Cold) $9.95 $10.30

Parmesan-style subs suit diners who want a warm, saucy sandwich. The Italian, ham, salami, and turkey subs are lighter deli-style alternatives. Confirm bread, cheese, and sauce choices if you have dietary restrictions.

Chittenango Pizza Pasta and Italian Dinners

Alongside pizza, the restaurant lists classic Italian-American dinners. Its published menu says dinner entrées include bread and butter, with a salad available for an additional $1.95 cash.

Italian Dinner Cash Card
Ziti or Spaghetti $10.95 $11.33
Ziti or Spaghetti with Meatballs or Sausage $13.95 $14.44
Chicken Parmesan with Pasta $15.95 $16.51
Eggplant Parmesan with Pasta $15.95 $16.51
Chicken Riggies $15.95 $16.51
Sausage Riggies $15.95 $16.51
Chicken Broccoli Alfredo with Fettuccine $15.95 $16.51
Penne alla Vodka $15.95 $16.51
Baked Ziti, Ravioli or Stuffed Shells $12.95 $13.40
Lasagna $13.95 $14.44
Fettuccine in Alfredo Sauce $13.95 $14.44
Fettuccine Carbonara with Ham and Mushroom $15.95 $16.51

Chicken riggies are a Central New York pasta favorite, making them a particularly local choice. For a creamy dish, consider fettuccine Alfredo; for a tomato-based pasta, spaghetti or penne alla vodka may be more appealing.

Salads, Friday Fish Fry, Drinks and Desserts

The menu also covers lighter salads, a Friday fish special, soft drinks, and desserts.

Item Cash Card
Small House Salad $3.95 $4.09
Large House Salad $7.95 $8.23
Antipasto, Grilled Chicken or Greek Salad $10.95 $11.33
Friday Fish Dinner with Fries and Coleslaw $13.95 $14.44
Friday Fish Sub with Fries $13.95 $14.44
20 oz Beverage $2.55 $2.64
2-Liter Beverage $3.95 $4.09
Cannoli $3.95 $4.09
Cheesecake or Chocolate Cake $4.95 $5.12

Friday fish fry availability can change; call ahead if that is the dish you specifically want. Desserts are convenient for adding a sweet finish to a takeout order.

Chittenango Pizza Address, Phone and Opening Hours

Detail Information
Restaurant Chittenango Pizza
Address 500 Genesee St, Chittenango, NY 13037
Phone (315) 510-2000
Monday 10:00 AM–9:00 PM
Tuesday Closed
Wednesday–Thursday 10:00 AM–9:00 PM
Friday–Saturday 10:00 AM–10:00 PM
Sunday 11:00 AM–9:00 PM

These are publicly listed regular hours, not a promise of service on holidays or special-event dates. Chittenango Pizza is associated with takeout and delivery in local directories. Call to confirm current delivery coverage, the ordering process, and any pickup-only specials.

Frequently Asked Questions

How much is a large cheese pizza at Chittenango Pizza?

The published menu lists a large cheese pizza at $16.50 cash or $17.08 by card. Confirm current pricing before ordering.

Does Chittenango Pizza have specialty pizzas?

Yes. Published choices include Deluxe, Chicken Wing, Chicken Bacon Ranch, Meat Lovers, Veggie, Steak, Hawaiian, and Mediterranean pizzas, with medium and large sizes listed.

Does Chittenango Pizza serve wings?

Yes. The published menu includes traditional and boneless wings, sauce options, and pizza-and-wings bundles. A 12-piece traditional wing order is listed at $14.95 cash.

What is the cheapest published pizza option?

The medium cauliflower pizza is listed at $11.95 cash before toppings, while the medium regular cheese pizza is listed at $13.95 cash. Cauliflower pizzas may have a different serving size or crust and should not be compared without checking details.

Does Chittenango Pizza offer gluten-free pizza?

A medium cauliflower-base pizza appears on the published menu, but this does not establish that it is certified gluten-free or safe for someone with celiac disease. Ask about ingredients, shared equipment, and cross-contact.

Does Chittenango Pizza have pasta dinners?

Yes. Published dinners include spaghetti, ziti, lasagna, ravioli, fettuccine Alfredo, chicken Parmesan, chicken riggies, sausage riggies, and penne alla vodka.

Is Chittenango Pizza open on Tuesday?

Publicly listed regular hours show Tuesday as closed. Holiday hours may differ.

Where is Chittenango Pizza located?

The restaurant is at 500 Genesee Street in Chittenango, New York 13037. Its listed phone number is (315) 510-2000.

Final Thoughts

The Chittenango Pizza menu has options for everything from a simple cheese pie to a pizza-and-wing family special. Its Italian dinners, subs, garlic knots, and Friday fish fry expand the choices beyond pizza. Use the published cash-versus-card tables for planning, but call the restaurant to verify the latest menu, pricing, and availability before ordering.

You may also read: Marco’s Pizza Menu With Prices (2026): Pizzas, Wings, Subs & More.

Image placeholder

REVIEWED BY MCCREY GUILLORY
Coffee Expert at Coca-Cola HBC M.Sc. University of Vienna

Every brew ratio, extraction timing, and flavor breakdown on this page has been audited for specialty coffee accuracy and bean quality.

Leave a Comment