Looking for the New Penny Cafe menu before stopping in for breakfast or coffee? This locally owned Avondale café serves breakfast sandwiches, burritos, fresh toast, lunch wraps, creative espresso drinks, smoothies and house-made treats. You can also find brunch-friendly choices for kids.
Below are published U.S. dollar prices from New Penny Cafe’s official Toast ordering menu checked in October 2026. Food entries show the listed online price; “From” on drinks means the smallest or base price shown, before size changes or add-ons. Prices and availability can differ in-store or by ordering method.
New Penny Cafe Breakfast Menu With Prices
Breakfast is a big part of the New Penny Cafe menu, with sandwiches, burritos, bowls and sweet dishes. The BLVD Burrito combines eggs, penny potatoes, cheese and chipotle aioli with a choice of meat. The café also makes its own English muffins.
| Menu Item | Online Price |
|---|---|
| Sausage, Egg and Cheese Sandwich | $9.00 |
| BEC-ky Sandwich | $11.00 |
| Big Boy Bagel Sandwich | $12.00 |
| Chicken and Waffle Sando | $12.00 |
| Black Bean Sandwich (vegetarian) | $14.00 |
| Breakfast Crunch Pocket Wrap | $14.00 |
| BLVD Burrito | $14.00 |
| California Breakfast Burrito | $15.00 |
| Tacos AM | $9.00 |
| Low Carb Power Bowl | $9.00 |
| French Toast Bites | $12.00 |
| Traditional Breakfast Plate | $12.00 |
The Toast ordering page also lists Biscuits & Gravy, Breakfast TOT-chos and a Cheesy Green Chile Burrito, but showed them as out of stock when checked.
Avocado Toast, Bagels, Sides & Bowls
For a lighter brunch, choose a bagel, avocado toast or a fruit-based bowl. The smoothie bowls are served in cups for takeaway.
Artisan toast and bagels
| Menu Item | Online Price |
|---|---|
| Bagel and Cream Cheese | $4.50 |
| Lavandula — lavender cream cheese and berries | $10.00 |
| Classic Avo | $12.00 |
| Avo Smash and Dash | From $9.00 |
Sides and smoothie bowls
| Menu Item | Online Price |
|---|---|
| Penny Potatoes | $4.00 |
| Two Potato Patties | $4.00 |
| French Fries | $4.00 |
| Pepper Jack Cheese Curds | $6.00 |
| Fruit Bowl | $6.00 |
| Yogurt Parfait | $7.00 |
| Açaí Bowl | $14.00 |
| Dragon Fruit Bowl | $14.00 |
| Ocean Water Bowl | $14.00 |
Brown Sugar Oatmeal, Fruit N Nut Oatmeal and Apple Harvest Oatmeal appeared on the online menu at $6.00 each but were marked out of stock. The Biscuit Flight was also marked out of stock.
New Penny Cafe Lunch Menu: Sandwiches and Wraps
Lunch focuses on generously filled sandwiches and wraps. The BBLT features thick-cut bacon, arugula, tomato and roasted-vegetable aioli on toasted multigrain bread. Several sandwiches offer a choice of side.
| Menu Item | Online Price |
|---|---|
| Chicken Bacon Ranch Wrap | $13.00 |
| Mexican Chicken Caesar Salad Wrap | $13.00 |
| BBLT Sandwich | $14.00 |
| Gobbler Turkey Sandwich | $14.00 |
| Sonoran Turkey Sandwich | $14.00 |
| Chicken Salad Sandwich | $14.00 |
A Green Chile Chicken Tortilla Soup is listed from $6.00, but it was marked out of stock on the menu checked.
New Penny Cafe Signature Latte Menu
The signature lattes make this Avondale coffee shop more than a standard drip-coffee stop. Expect flavors such as vanilla bean, toasted cinnamon, cookie butter and peanut butter candy cream.
| Menu Item | Online Price |
|---|---|
| Tres Leches Latte | From $5.95 |
| Mojave Vanilla Bean | From $5.50 |
| Toasted Cinnamon | From $5.50 |
| Copper Coin | From $5.75 |
| PB Mazapan | From $5.50 |
| Buttercrunch S’mores | From $5.50 |
| Cookie Butter | From $5.50 |
| Caramelita Latte | From $5.50 |
| Zebra Mocha | From $5.50 |
| Mocha | From $5.50 |
| White Mocha | From $5.50 |
The Tres Leches Latte includes a dairy-based tri-milk blend and is not offered dairy-free. Sugar-free versions of Copper Coin, Buttercrunch S’mores and Cookie Butter also appear on the online menu.
Regular Coffee, Espresso & Cold Brew Prices
If you prefer less sweetness, the everyday coffee menu covers drip coffee, cold brew, Americanos and classic espresso-and-milk drinks.
| Menu Item | Online Price |
|---|---|
| House Blend Drip | From $3.00 |
| Decaf Drip | From $3.00 |
| Iced Coffee | From $3.00 |
| Decaf Iced Coffee | From $3.00 |
| Cold Brew | From $4.50 |
| Hot Latte | From $4.80 |
| Iced Latte | From $4.80 |
| Hot Americano | From $3.40 |
| Iced Americano | From $3.40 |
| Cappuccino | From $4.50 |
Seasonal Drinks and Fall 2026 Specials
New Penny Cafe updates its drink selection during the year. Its October 2026 online menu includes pumpkin, apple pie, shaken espresso and matcha specials. These are seasonal choices rather than permanent menu promises.
| Menu Item | Online Price |
|---|---|
| Brown Sugar Cinnamon Shaken Espresso | From $5.75 |
| Cinderella Shaken Espresso | From $5.75 |
| Berry Cheesecake Shaken Espresso | From $6.75 |
| Caramel Cookie Shaken Espresso | From $5.75 |
| Pumpkin Latte — hot | From $5.15 |
| Pumpkin Latte — iced | From $5.00 |
| Pumpkin Cheesecake Latte — hot or iced | From $5.75 |
| Apple Pie Chai — hot or iced | From $6.50 |
| Maple Blondie — hot or iced | From $5.50 |
| Monster Matcha — hot or iced | From $6.50 |
| Dulce Horchata Shaken Espresso | From $6.50 |
Matcha, Tea, Smoothies, Lemonade & Lotus Drinks
There are plenty of alternatives to espresso. Matcha, fruit smoothies, flavored lemonades and Lotus energy drinks all have their own menu categories. Lotus beverages contain an energy base; the Twilight Italian Soda is specifically presented as a non-energy option.
Tea and lemonade — starting prices
| Menu Item | Online Price |
|---|---|
| Matcha Latte | From $6.20 |
| Chai Latte | From $5.55 |
| Iced Tea | From $3.75 |
| Hot Tea | From $2.40 |
| Specialty Lemonades | From $3.75 |
| Original Lemonade | From $2.95 |
Protein and fruit smoothies — starting prices
| Menu Item | Online Price |
|---|---|
| PB and Jelly Protein Smoothie | From $8.00 |
| Chocolate Peanut Butter Protein Smoothie | From $8.00 |
| Strawberry Yogurt Smoothie | From $4.75 |
| Fruit Smoothie — mango, strawberry or peach | From $4.75 |
| Banana Matcha | From $5.25 |
| Mango Dragonfruit | From $4.75 |
| Mango-cita | From $5.00 |
| Power Puff | From $5.50 |
Lotus energy drinks and soda — starting prices
| Menu Item | Online Price |
|---|---|
| Sedona Lotus | From $5.85 |
| Sour Plant Lotus | From $5.85 |
| Gila Monster Lotus | From $5.85 |
| Monsoon Lotus | From $5.85 |
| Build Your Own Lotus | From $5.85 |
| Twilight Lotus | From $6.60 |
| Strawberry Coolada | From $5.85 |
| Friday Night Lights | From $6.60 |
| Autumn Glow | From $6.60 |
| Twilight Italian Soda — no energy | From $6.15 |
| Soda | From $2.50 |
Frappe Menu With Prices
The blended drinks are useful when you want a sweeter cold coffee rather than a standard iced latte. Toppings and other customizations may increase the price.
| Menu Item | Online Price |
|---|---|
| Cookie Coffee Frappe | From $6.00 |
| Copper Coin Coffee Frappe | From $6.00 |
| Caramel Frappe | From $6.00 |
| Mocha Frappe | From $6.00 |
| Build Your Own Frappe | From $6.00 |
Kids Menu, Drinks & House-Made Treats
Families can order smaller savory meals, simple drinks and sweets. New Penny Cafe also highlights its in-house baking, including cookies and other rotating baked goods.
Kids meals
| Menu Item | Online Price |
|---|---|
| Kids Chicken Strips and Fries | $7.00 |
| Chicken Waffle Nuggets | $7.00 |
| Potato Plate | $7.00 |
| Kids Yogurt Sundae | $6.00 |
| Turkey and Cheddar Croissant | $7.00 |
Kids drinks and sweets
| Menu Item | Online Price |
|---|---|
| Shirley Temple | From $3.00 |
| Funfetti Frappe | $4.60 |
| Chocolate Milk | $3.45 |
| Orange Juice | $4.03 |
| Kids Hot Chocolate | $3.45 |
| Caramel Creme Frappe | $4.00 |
| Milk | From $2.25 |
| Cake Pops | $4.89 |
| Cowboy Cookie | $3.75 |
| Chocolate Chip Cookie | $3.75 |
| Gluten-Free Peanut Butter Cookie | $3.75 |
The Cowboy Cookie contains nuts. The peanut butter cookie is described as gluten-free, but guests with allergies should confirm food-handling procedures directly with staff.
New Penny Cafe Location, Hours and Ordering
| Details | Information |
|---|---|
| Address | 735 N 114th Ave, Avondale, AZ 85323 |
| Phone | (623) 249-4192 |
| Opening Hours | Daily, 6:00 a.m.–3:00 p.m. |
| Online Ordering Window | Daily, 6:00 a.m.–2:45 p.m. (as listed on Toast) |
| Service | Counter service; pickup and delivery offered through online ordering |
New Penny Cafe is near Avondale Boulevard and I-10. The restaurant also advertises crafted cocktails, an event space and local makers’ products, although its published food-and-drink ordering menu does not establish cocktail or private-event prices.
Dietary Options and What to Order
For a substantial breakfast, the BLVD Burrito or Chicken and Waffle Sando is a natural choice. For lunch, the BBLT and Gobbler offer different takes on familiar sandwiches. Customers looking for a meat-free breakfast can consider the Black Bean Sandwich or avocado toast, while smoothie bowls provide fruit-forward options.
The café lists a gluten-free peanut butter cookie and has identified certain oatmeal options as gluten-free, though the oatmeal was not available when checked. Some specialty drinks contain dairy, gluten or nuts, so confirm ingredients and cross-contact with staff if you have allergies. The menu also includes sugar-free flavored latte options; sugar-free flavoring does not necessarily make the full drink sugar-free.
Frequently Asked Questions
Where is New Penny Cafe?
It is at 735 N 114th Ave, Avondale, AZ 85323, close to Avondale Boulevard and Interstate 10.
What are New Penny Cafe opening hours?
The café lists 6:00 a.m. to 3:00 p.m. daily. Its online ordering service shows an earlier cutoff of 2:45 p.m.
Is New Penny Cafe counter service?
Yes. The restaurant describes itself as a counter-service café serving breakfast, brunch, lunch, coffee and crafted cocktails.
Does New Penny Cafe have vegetarian food?
Yes. The breakfast menu identifies its house-made Black Bean Sandwich as vegetarian, and there are avocado-toast and smoothie-bowl options. Check sauces and toppings if needed.
Are gluten-free options available?
The menu lists a gluten-free peanut butter cookie and describes some oatmeal as gluten-free, although the oatmeal was out of stock when checked. Ask staff about allergens and cross-contact.
Does New Penny Cafe offer pickup or delivery?
Its Toast ordering page provides pickup and delivery options, subject to availability at the time and your delivery address.
Does New Penny Cafe serve cocktails?
Yes, the café advertises crafted cocktails, but a reliable current cocktail price list was not available from the online menu checked.
Are the online prices the same as dine-in prices?
Not necessarily. The tables above reflect the prices visible on its online ordering menu; choices of size, milk, extras and ordering method can affect the total.
Final Thoughts
New Penny Cafe is a convenient Avondale stop if you want more than a standard coffee shop menu. Between hearty breakfasts, sandwiches, matcha, specialty lattes, blended drinks and house-made cookies, there are choices for a quick morning pickup or a relaxed brunch. Check the ordering menu before visiting for the latest availability and total price.
You may also read: What Makes a Great Coffee Shop?
