Looking for the Sicilian Bella Festa menu before making a trip to West Wyoming, Pennsylvania? This casual pizza-and-ice-cream spot is known for crispy-bottomed, pan-fried Sicilian pizza, Detroit-style pies, cheesesteaks, wings, and a dessert counter. The restaurant sits along Abrahams Creek at 835 Shoemaker Avenue, making it an easy choice for a relaxed takeout dinner or an outdoor meal.
This guide brings together the published menu, available price examples, pizza choices, opening hours, and ordering tips. Important: the figures below come from publicly posted menu photographs and third-party menu records. They are useful reference prices, but they have not been independently confirmed as the restaurant’s current October 2026 prices. Pizza sizes and toppings can affect the final bill.
Sicilian Bella Festa Pizza Menu With Prices
Pizza is the main attraction here. The pan-fried Sicilian style has a browned, crisp underside with a softer center, while Detroit-style pizza offers a different square-pie experience. Local coverage also highlights sweet garlic sauce, white pies, broccoli combinations, and regional favorites such as pagash.
The following prices are taken from a published third-party menu transcription. The listing does not consistently identify which cut count or size each amount represents; the original photographed menu shows multiple sizes for many pizzas. Confirm your preferred size when ordering.
| Pizza | Published Reference Price |
|---|---|
| Red Pizza | $20.00 |
| Red Sweet Garlic Pizza | $23.00 |
| Sausage, Pepper & Onion Pizza | $26.95 |
| White Pizza | $24.95 |
| Double Crust White Pizza | $20.00 |
| 3 Cheese Broccoli Pizza | $26.95 |
| Dante’s Inferno Pizza | $25.95 |
| Veggie Pizza | $27.95 |
| Meat Lovers Pizza | Varies by size; check menu |
| Detroit-Style Pizza | Check current price |
| Pagash (Pierogi) Pizza | Check current price |
| Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza | Check current price |
The older menu records sometimes give different figures for the same pizza, particularly Meat Lovers, Veggie, and Dante’s Inferno. Those differences are why this guide does not treat every listed amount as a fixed tray price. The photographed restaurant menu separates some pies into six-, eight-, and twelve-cut options.
Pan-Fried Sicilian Pizza
If this is your first visit, the red pizza or red sweet garlic variety is a straightforward introduction. The signature texture comes from the pan-fried crust: a crisp bottom, browned edges, and a substantial slice. An April 2024 visit by the local Times Leader described the red pizza with onions, while more recent regional guides continue to feature the pan-fried version as the house specialty.
These are filling, tray-style pizzas, so check both the cut count and the number of people eating before choosing a size. Adding onions, peppers, meat, or another topping may change the cost.
White, Broccoli & Specialty Pizzas
Prefer pizza without the usual red sauce? White Pizza and 3 Cheese Broccoli are established menu choices. The Double Crust White is another option for customers who enjoy a richer, more substantial pie. Specialty names also include Dante’s Inferno, a spicier choice, and the regional pagash or pierogi-style pizza, which centers on potato, onion, and cheese rather than a conventional tomato-sauce topping.
Local restaurant guides additionally mention pickle pizza, hot wing pizza, white rosemary, and barbecue-chicken combinations. These are useful options to ask about, although the available public sources do not establish a current price or guarantee daily availability for every specialty.
Sicilian Bella Festa Cheesesteak Menu
Pizza is not the only dinner choice. The photographed menu includes beef and chicken cheesesteaks, a Buffalo version, and a chicken bacon ranch combination. The restaurant’s menu-board photograph and a published transcription provide the following reference prices.
| Cheesesteak | Published Reference Price |
|---|---|
| Beef Cheesesteak | $13.95 |
| Chicken Cheesesteak | $13.95 |
| Buffalo Chicken Cheesesteak | $13.50 |
| Chicken Bacon Ranch Cheesesteak | $14.25 |
| Gluten-Free Cheesesteak Option | $10.50 |
The menu photo shows additional cheesesteak customization options, including onions, peppers, cheese, and other toppings. Because the final preparation can vary, ask which additions are included and which cost extra. The gluten-free listing should not be treated as a guarantee of an allergen-free preparation area; anyone with celiac disease or a serious wheat allergy should confirm ingredients and cross-contact procedures directly.
Chicken Wings, Boneless Bites & Fries
For something to share with pizza, Sicilian Bella Festa also offers wings, boneless wing bites, and fries. A published photograph of its orange takeout menu shows wing quantities and the following prices. Since the photograph is not a live October 2026 ordering system, treat them as older reference amounts.
| Item | Photographed Menu Price |
|---|---|
| 12 Wings | $16.90 |
| 20 Wings | $26.00 |
| 40 Wings | $52.00 |
| Boneless Wing Bites, 1/2 lb | $7.75 |
| Boneless Wing Bites, 1 lb | $14.50 |
| Small Fries | $3.95 |
| Large Fries | $5.00 |
The photographed wing menu lists a broad selection of sauces, ranging from milder flavors to hotter choices. Customer reviews also mention crispy wings and boneless bites, including a popular boom boom-style option. Ask which sauces and dipping dressings are currently offered, particularly when ordering large quantities for a group.
Loaded fries are another option mentioned in local dining coverage. The extra toppings and their prices are not consistently documented in the public listings, so the standard fry prices above should not be assumed to include cheese, bacon, chili, or other additions.
Hot Dogs, Sandwiches & Other Savory Food
One of the more distinctive items is Renee’s Famous Foot Long Chili Dog. A local pizza reviewer specifically highlights the generous chili topping and onions, making it a logical choice if you want something other than pizza. The available sources also mention a slow-roasted barbecue pork sandwich and other handheld choices.
| Additional Menu Item | Current Price Availability |
|---|---|
| Renee’s Famous Foot Long Chili Dog | Not reliably published |
| Barbecue Pork Sandwich | Not reliably published |
| Loaded Fries | Depends on toppings |
| Extra Cheesesteak Toppings | Check when ordering |
These options make the menu practical for a group with different preferences: some people can order a tray of pizza while others choose wings or sandwiches. If you are collecting several made-to-order dishes, placing a phone order ahead of time can make pickup easier.
Sicilian Bella Festa Ice Cream Menu
There is a separate ice cream counter at Sicilian Bella Festa, so dessert is a meaningful part of the experience rather than an afterthought. Local visitors and regional tourism listings describe soft serve, hand-dipped ice cream, sundaes, milkshakes, and assorted toppings.
| Ice Cream or Dessert Option | Price |
|---|---|
| Soft-Serve Cone | Ask at counter |
| Hand-Dipped Ice Cream | Ask at counter |
| Ice Cream Sundae | Ask at counter |
| Milkshake | Ask at counter |
| Flurry-Style Ice Cream Treat | Ask at counter |
| Dairy-Free Ice Cream Options | Ask about availability |
Reviews mention toppings such as crushed cherries, pineapple, chocolate sprinkles, and candy pieces. Some customers have also reported dairy-free chocolate or vanilla ice cream. Flavors and toppings may rotate, and a complete, dated 2026 price list for the ice cream counter was not available from the sources checked.
What Should You Order First?
If you’re mainly visiting for pizza, start with a pan-fried red or sweet garlic pie. These choices showcase the crust and sauce that earned the restaurant its local reputation. For a group, pairing a pizza with wings makes it easier to sample two major sections of the menu.
Customers looking for a less familiar regional specialty can ask about pagash pizza, while those who prefer chicken flavors might consider Buffalo chicken cheesesteaks or hot wing pizza. Finish with a cone, sundae, or shake if the dessert counter is operating when you visit.
It is worth checking the availability of special pizzas before you drive over. Not every menu photograph or older review represents what is being prepared on a particular evening.
Location, Opening Hours & Ordering
Sicilian Bella Festa is located at 835 Shoemaker Avenue, West Wyoming, PA 18644. The publicly listed contact number is (570) 885-2118. The restaurant operates mainly as a takeout-window spot, with outdoor picnic-table seating near Abrahams Creek. It is not a conventional full-service indoor dining room.
| Day | Published Hours |
|---|---|
| Monday | Closed |
| Tuesday | Closed |
| Wednesday | Closed |
| Thursday | 3:00 PM–8:00 PM |
| Friday | 3:00 PM–8:00 PM |
| Saturday | 3:00 PM–8:00 PM |
| Sunday | 3:00 PM–7:00 PM |
These hours are consistent across recent restaurant directories, but they can change for holidays, weather, or special events. Call before making a long trip. Outdoor seating is especially pleasant in good weather; however, it may not be practical on rainy or cold days. Several local reviews mention limited parking at busy times.
Takeout is well documented, but third-party listings disagree about delivery and payment options. Rather than relying on a delivery-app claim, contact the restaurant to confirm whether delivery is available to your address and which payment methods it currently accepts. Some older local coverage advises bringing cash.
Vegetarian, Vegan & Gluten-Free Choices
Vegetarian diners can look into the Veggie Pizza, 3 Cheese Broccoli Pizza, and other meat-free combinations, subject to ingredients and preparation. Dairy-based cheese means these regular pizzas should not automatically be considered vegan. Customer reports mention some vegan pizza and dairy-free ice cream options, but their current availability needs confirmation.
A gluten-free cheesesteak option appears on the photographed menu. Anyone managing a food allergy should speak with staff before ordering, particularly because a kitchen making standard pizza and sandwiches may handle wheat, milk, and other common allergens nearby.
Frequently Asked Questions About Sicilian Bella Festa
Where is Sicilian Bella Festa located?
It is at 835 Shoemaker Avenue, West Wyoming, Pennsylvania 18644, near Abrahams Creek.
What type of pizza does Sicilian Bella Festa serve?
It is best known for pan-fried Sicilian trays and also offers Detroit-style pizza and specialty combinations such as sweet garlic, white, and broccoli pizzas.
How much is Sicilian Bella Festa pizza?
Published menu references include a Red Pizza at $20 and White Pizza at $24.95, but these prices may refer to different sizes and should not be treated as confirmed October 2026 prices.
Does Sicilian Bella Festa have chicken wings?
Yes. An older photographed menu lists 12-, 20-, and 40-piece wing orders, along with boneless bites and multiple sauces.
Are cheesesteaks available?
Yes. Published menu references include beef, chicken, Buffalo chicken, and chicken bacon ranch cheesesteaks.
Does Sicilian Bella Festa sell ice cream?
Yes. Its ice cream counter offers several kinds of frozen desserts, including cones, sundaes, and shakes, with flavors and availability subject to change.
Can you eat inside the restaurant?
Local reports describe a takeout-window operation with outdoor picnic-table seating rather than a traditional indoor dining room.
What are Sicilian Bella Festa’s opening hours?
Recent listings show Thursday through Saturday, 3–8 PM, and Sunday, 3–7 PM, with Monday through Wednesday closed. Confirm hours by phone before visiting.
Final Thoughts
Sicilian Bella Festa brings together crispy pan-fried pizza, distinctive regional specials, familiar sandwiches, wings, and ice cream in a casual West Wyoming setting. The red sweet garlic pizza is a natural starting point, while white broccoli pizza, cheesesteaks, and the footlong chili dog give returning visitors more to explore.
Use the prices in this guide as published reference points, not a guaranteed current quote. Calling ahead is the simplest way to confirm sizes, special orders, and pickup timing before your visit.
You may also read: What Makes a Great Coffee Shop?
